Showing posts with label Outrage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Outrage. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 1

Erratum

I am publishing here some of my comments on a rather erroneous article, be it by the reporter or the interviewee...


Sunday June 28, 2009

Irish connection

By TAN SHIOW CHIN

WHEN Penang Medical College (PMC) began 13 years ago, it was the norm for students on twinning programmes to start off their studies in Malaysia, before proceeding abroad to complete their degree.

This, in fact, was the modus operandi for the first private medical college in Malaysia — the International Medical College, which is now the International Medical University (IMU).

Final-year medical students studying hard for their exams at the college library.

IMU students on the twinning programme spend their first two-and-a-half years in Malaysia, then proceed on to their clinical studies at one of IMU’s partner medical schools abroad.

PMC, however, along with the now-defunct Asean-Sheffield Medical College in Ipoh, came up with the concept of first sending students abroad for their pre-clinical studies before returning to Malaysia to continue with their clinical years.

According to PMC president Brendan Lyons, this model gives the students the best of both worlds.

“We take them out of Malaysia first and shake them up a bit. They are exposed to vigorous scientific training and have to perform on par with their fellow students at either the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland (RCSI) or University College Dublin (UCD).

The word is not perform on par. IF you were to look back to the past couple of years, the PMC students have been setting the standards for the university, with the students performing beyond the level of the other students in the university, winning numerous medals, and competitions as well as topping the examinations in their respective classes...Just highlighting a point here.

“Then they come back to Penang, where they are exposed to the clinical setting, and patterns of disease and healthcare issues in Malaysia.”

The difference is significant as the clinical scenario in Ireland and Malaysia are naturally different.

“For example, you are hardly likely to see malaria or dengue cases in Ireland. You are more likely to see cardiovascular cases in Europe,” says Lyons.

This is a very bad example to give. We are talking about Ireland anyway, and the best example IMHO is that of cystic fibrosis. We see numerous cardiovascular cases in Malaysia as well.

An added bonus to this model is that parents and students can also save on the more expensive clinical-year tuition fees, as well as the expenses of living those two-and-a-half years abroad.

I truly doubt it is an "added" bonus, more likely to be the MAIN REASON why parents send their children here

Lyons adds that there is another benefit in the larger context in using this model.

“From a national point of view, there is a higher likelihood of our graduates staying on and working in Malaysia,” he says, adding that only around 70 of their over-500 graduates to date have opted to work in Singapore, while only a small number have gone back to practise in Ireland.

The error here is not that the students have "opted" to work in Singapore, but that those who have succeeded in getting into the system there. The problem is that there seems to be an internal struggle for a graduate from PMC to leave Malaysia as they are not given the support they need to do so...

As such, it is not surprising that about two-thirds of their students are Public Services Department (PSD) or Mara scholars.

Why is it not surprising? It is not surprising because it is cheaper for JPA and MARA, not because of the model.

PMC graduates receive an MB BCh BAO (Bachelor of Medicine, Bachelor of Surgery, Bachelor of Obstetrics) degree awarded by the National University of Ireland, which RCSI and UCD are a part of.

This statement is correct

This degree is recognised by the Malaysian Medical Council, Irish Medical Council and Singapore Medical Council among others.

This statement is also technically correct, but is very misleading. The MBBChBAO is recognised by SMC, but only if you have pursued your course in Ireland for the whole 5 years. The SMC does not recognise the degree awarded to PMC students because they are under a twinning programme, and have not pursed the whole course in Ireland. Therefore, PMC graduates are not allowed to work in Singapore.

Graduates also receive the Licentiates of the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland (LRCSI) and the Licentiates of the Royal College of Physicians in Ireland (LRCPI), which are licenses given by the university, as an authorised body, to the holder to practise surgery and medicine respectively.

These are historical licentiates which bear no extra value to the degree, but are conferred due to historical value.

New developments

The college, which uses the Penang General Hospital as its main teaching hospital, intends to gradually increase its student intake to about 150 a year.

Says Lyons: “We will recruit 130 first-year students for our next intake, and will increase the number by ten a year until we reach 150.”

He explains that the reason for gradually increasing the numbers is to ensure that there are sufficient clinical places available.

“We can’t expect to dump a whole lot of clinical students on our teaching hospitals and expect them to cope,” he says.

Lyons adds that at present, the hospitals PMC works with have the capacity for expansion, but the college also wants to ensure that they are not overburdened and that their students get the proper medical training.

The college is also exploring the possibility of working with other hospitals and clinics. For example, PMC has arranged with Taiping Hospital to allow their final-year students to do their two-week houseman shadowing module there starting this year.

Aside from expanding the clinical side of the programme, the college has also started conducting the Pre-Med, or Foundation Year, programme at the PMC campus on Jalan Sepoy Lines.

The programme, which started two years ago, takes in students who made it to the interview stage, but are not quite academically-qualified to go straight into the five-year medical course.

Previously, students had to go straight to Ireland to study this course, resulting in them spending a total of three-and-a-half years abroad with the attending extra expenditure.

“We thought it was important to pick up these students, especially those who were really interested in medicine, and prepare them to study in Ireland,” shares Lyons.

He adds that based on the feedback from both RCSI and UCD, the first batch of 17 students, who are now completing their first year of medical studies in Ireland, are doing as well as those who entered straight into the five-year programme.

The college also recently purchased the Penang Home Building in Jalan Residency, next to the Penang General Hospital.

ERROR. PMC has not purchased the building, but instead have loaned it for a 9 year period (the exact details are complicated) for about ~RM20000 per month.

According to Lyons, the purchase will increase the capacity of the college by about 25% in terms of building space.

ERROR: PMC has not purchased the building. It will increase the PMC grass and lawn space by 25%, but it will also reduced the library space by 66% and the student centre space if the proposed move happens.

Aside from improving and expanding on current facilities, the extra capacity will be used for the proposed new Diploma in Radiography programme to be introduced next year.

Says Lyons: “We have been looking at expanding our programmes in detail for the past number of years.

“We are actually looking at introducing a Diploma in Radiography next year.”

He adds that the content of the programme will be mostly, if not all, taken from UCD, and will be accredited by the university. However, the programme will be run entirely in Penang.

The college is also looking at programmes in physiotherapy, pharmacy and hospital management, but will focus on introducing one programme at a time for now.


Click here to read the original publication in theStar online

Thursday, April 2

Orientation???

Where is the list of panel doctors which the students are entitled to free consultations?

Where is the list for of members of faculty who are supposed to act as mentors?

Where is the person who is supposed to ask us if we have taken the LAN subjects, and if not when they will be held?

Where is the accountability from tutors and lecturers for not turning up without warning, or being late and keep us waiting, but turn on you for being late is they are on time?

Where is the system put in place to notify students of delays, cancellations, postponements?

Who is paying the students to notify each other about information that should be disseminated from the college or the faculty centre?

Who do you blame when there is no pointer for the lecturer in class?

Why do the students need to pay for their accommodations while on rotations?

Why is there a lack of cohesiveness of the class, and a clear disparity between people from UCd and RCSI?

Why is there a sense of animosity and anonymity between students of different classes?

Why are the term dates not available beyond this semester?

Who do we blame for the lack of efficiency, and the "this is how it has always been done" attitude?

How can we improve on all this?

How do we get rid of this sense of moderation and lack of enthusiasm, and instead strive for excellence?

It's that time of month....

Wednesday, March 25

IMposition

I must say that I do not like things being imposed on me. Especially thing which are not part of the official curriculum.

Yes, some activities may be beneficial to me, but there is no need to impose it on me as though I was a little toddler, but rather I should be given the freedom of choice... especially when the other party stands to gain from it also.

It's like someone had a bright idea one day and decided that he would make it law!

Tuesday, January 13

An unusual post- a rant!!!

There is probably no other test in med school where you are told the content that is being examined, the details of how you will be examined, the actual marking sheet, and also be given the EXACT details of the content if you bothered to attend.

Even if you did not attend, you could just copy it from a friend- as it is going to be examined.

You are given MULTIPLE reminders- the TOSCE cases will be taken from you weekly module cases.

Yet, people choose to ignore this fact.

It reminds me of a chinese saying- 不听老人言, 吃亏在眼前. For those of you who do not understand mandarin, it's english equivalent is "if the old dog barks, he gives counsel". However, it's literal translation is more rich, when it actually states that if you do not listen to advice given, then your loss is right in front of your eyes.

Anyway, if I was the examiner, I would have failed everyone else in my group. It may seem harsh, but it's a fair fact.

If you had read the 15 cases you had (10 considering the fact that 5 had been used the previous day):

-You would have known right from the first question "What is your name?" - John Smith, that it was the exact same history as what you received for the module case titled "Renal calculi"

- You would have known the problems he has, and ask the relevant questions

- You would have been reminded that there are 10 questions you need to ask if a patient presents with pain

- You would have been alerted to the fact that you would need to ask questions related to the urinary system.

- You would have known been told what the investigations were for a renal calculi, including the use of the word "modality"

- You would have learned the different types of stones that present in the kidney

- You would have learned what kind of imaging you would use

- You would have come across how to treat this problem, both if it is big and small.

- You would not have looked blankly at the examiner as though you had a thyroid gaze!!!

If you had been to the ward tutorials:

-You would have been reminded that you need to wash your hands with the gel provided

-You neeed to ask the patient if he has any pain before you touch him

-You will have learned that there are 8 groups of lymph nodes in the cervical region and 5 in the axillary area, and you would have learned how to feel for them!!!

- You would have been told to practice eliciting a reflex, and how to properly position yourself so that you can actually swing the hammer without any problem!!!

And if you had been to the "Mock" Exam, you would have been given the EXACT mark sheet used, so that you could practice the tasks itinerised on it!!!!

SO if you didnt do the above, then you deserve to fail, but please, please do not involve ME in the process, do not pull my grades down because of your incompetence!!!

IF I have never seen you in class before, then you should fail your exams! Medicine isn't a distance learning course, if it was, I wouldn;t be here!!!

IF you are repeating the year, I expect you to at least know something, so that you will be able to pass this time round, instead of failing again!!!

IF you show upat 8.55am- 5 minutes before the exams, demanding to attend it, when you were given notice to be there at 8.30am, then you shouldn't be allowed to sit it!!!

n.b. I am not without flaw, but at least I take advice that is given, and I do my best- the rest is up to God and to fate. All I ask is that you do the same- take some advice, take this advice!!!

Monday, October 27

Religion outrage

I know I told my self, no more religiony posts when I restart my blog, but there are always exceptions...

I have just attended one of the most memorable Sunday "mass"es of my life. Albeit in the wrong way.

How do you consider valid and licit a mass where:
1. There is no Kyrie after the 'I confess'
2. 1 reading instead of 2
3. A homily by the priest who grabs the microphone and stands in the middle of the sanctuary
4. No creed
5. No 'Sanctus'
6. No preface
7. The eucharistic prayer is taken from the 'Canadian Bishops' for use in Ireland.
8. The priest does not consecrate the wine into the Body of Christ
9. Communion is then offered under 2 species
10. The closing prayer is composed spontaneously by the priest

This coming barely 2 weeks after a minister of the eucharist offers my Muslim friend to partake in Holy Communion in the lift of Beaumont Hospital....

Sacrilegious...

Sunday, May 11

Focus on the correct issue, please!

With reference to the problem of a shortage of doctors in the public service, it is mind boggling as to the steps the government are taking to correct this problem. Instead of focusing on how to interest doctors who have fulfilled their requirements in public service to stay and maybe rewarding them, they are turning their attention to how to lure doctors who are practicing abroad to come back.

Mind you, it is the experience people have working in the public service that irks them, so if this could be improved, it could maybe be more successful in the long term than to spend gazillions of ringgits to lure back doctors form overseas to plug the short term gap?

Could the latest reports that doctors who have practiced overseas may not be required to perform the compulsory 3 years service to the government be another one of those women-will-have-to-get-permission-from-family-members- before-they-go-overseas statements, or is it one of the PGCC-type projects, or could it be like the Petronas Twin Towers short-lived reality, because the focus here is totally wrong.

Sunday, April 13

Grads prefer to stay on overseas...

This article in this mornings newspaper caught my eyes, not only because I am involved indirectly but also because we were just discussing it over dinner last Friday and the officials refused to disclose the figures only for their boss to leak it out a week later...

PUTRAJAYA: More and more medical students sent abroad to study on government scholarships, many costing more than a million ringgit each, are breaking their 10-year bond by refusing to return and serve in public hospitals.

“This is a sore point with us. In 2006, 21 medical students in Britain did not return. Last year, the number was 63. For those studying in Ireland, three students did not come back in 2006 while last year, 27 did not return,” said Human Capital Development division director Datin Madinah Mohamad.

She said these students cost the Government up to RM1.1mil each in funding for the five-year course.

“The number has been steadily increasing each year since 2003. The excuse these undergraduates often give is that they want to do their two-year housemanship over there and continue with sub-specialisation courses.

“But when they do so, they may then get employed and become eligible for registration in Britain. With the pay they are getting there, it’s highly unlikely they will come back and serve here,” she said in an interview here yesterday.

Since 2003, 145 students from Britain and 85 from Ireland have not come back. However, only three from Russia, two from Jordan and one from Japan failed to return.

Another reason many students chose to stay back could have been due to PSD’s perceived lenient treatment of such students in the past and a paltry penalty of RM160,000 each before 2003, she said.

“It encouraged undergraduates, who have seen many of their seniors being let off, to follow suit,” she said.

Although the department had officers in Britain and Ireland to track down errant medical students, some in the last year of studies ignored notices and others did not bother to show up when called for interviews.

She said tougher measures were needed to make them come back and serve or pay their bond.

The department was now seriously considering suggestions to make errant students repay twice or thrice the sum of their scholarships as punishment.

“We need to study this recommendation,” she said, adding the department had also handed 30 such cases since 1989 to the Attorney-General’s Chambers for legal action and had even declared one former student bankrupt.

But legal action was slow and guarantors would be taken to court only as the last resort, she said.

Since PSD’s Overseas Scholarship Programme started in 2000, RM2.15bil in scholarships had been given to 10,485 students up to the end of last year. Sim Leoi Leoi.

Wednesday, January 9

Weird and worrying stuff...

Cops go after Hindraf donors
Soon Li Tsin | Jan 9, 08 5:23pm

If you have made a donation to the Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf) movement, the police may be knocking on your door soon.

The Commercial Crime Investigation Department (CCID) has sent letters to individuals summoning them to give statements at the Bukit Aman police headquarters over a possible offence of funding a terrorist organisation.

The letter stated that the police are investigating this offence under Section 130N of the Penal Code - the funding of terrorist activities.

If found guilty, the person can be punished with death (if the terrorist act results in death), imprisonment for a term of not less than seven years but not exceeding 30 years and a fine.

“The police believe that you can provide a statement about funds given to Hindraf Enterprise,” read the letter signed by investigating officer ASP Rozeni Ismail.

A donor who received the letter and was quizzed by the police recently said references were made to a RHB bank account registered under the name ‘Hindraf Enterprise’.

The donor, who requested anonymity, said the police recorded statement in relation to some other offence - non-terrorism related - committed by the company.

“It is odd that the matter is being dealt by the Commercial Crimes Department because during questioning, they made no reference to the terrorist offences. They said the company could be charged for impropriety in soliciting donations and funds.

“It is also very alarming that the banks can give information about their clients and their transactions to the police without the need for a court order.”

Under the Section 16A of the Central Bank of Malaysia Act 1958, banks are permitted to convey any information in relation to any offences to the police or affected financial institutions.

Many being summoned

However, the donor pointed out that the recording of the statement took only 30 minutes and the police were pleasant throughout the period.

“I don’t think I am the only one. When I asked if there were others, the officer said there were many other people being summoned,” the donor added.

Hindraf gained fame when it organised a protest that saw 30,000 people hit the streets of Kuala Lumpur on Nov 25 last year.

This was followed by the movement’s leaders and supporters being charged for a slew of offences including sedition, causing mischief and attending an illegal assembly.

On Dec 8, 2007, the Companies Commission of Malaysia revoked the registration of Hindraf Enterprise for using the company for unlawful purposes and purposes prejudicial to national security and public order.

The company at that time had set up a bank account for the public to donate money to the cause and for those incarcerated in need of bail money.

At the height of enforcement action, enigmatic Hindraf leader P Uthayakumar with R Kenghadharan, M Manoharan, V Ganabathirau and T Vasanthakumar were arrested under the Internal Security Act on Dec 13 last year.

They have been detained for two years without trial.

CCID director ACP Mohd Kamarudin Md Din was unavailable to comment on this investigation when contacted.

(C) Malaysiakini.com

Will bloggers be next???

The Real CC Saga, and why I am and should be frustrated...

This was the first email I sent:

From: Mark Kiak Min Tan
Sent: Thu 11/22/2007 12:27 AM
To: Dr. XY
Subject: CC Revision Classes

Hi Dr. XY,

My name is Mark and I am currently in JC3. My CC group is group 11 with Dr. D.

As you may well know, we finished our last CC class for the term today, and we were told that for our OSCE exams, content from last years classes as well as this years will be examinable.

Anyway, I spoke to Dr. D about this and she said that she would be perfectly happy to give us a couple of extra practice classes (formal or informal) if we needed to, but she said she would need your approval for it as not all tutors may be willing to do so.

This is a private arrangement which she is happy to help out in if you agree to allowing it. It will not take place during Dr. D's scheduled clinical teaching hours in RCSI or during any of our class times. It will also be on a voluntary basis, and no one in the group will be forced to come if they do not want to, but I am sure that attendance will be quite good for this if it does happen.

As such, I hope that you will give your approval for this to happen.

Also, it would be good if you could provide some information about our OSCE exams for JC3. So far, all that we have been told is that the case studies which are examinable are from JC3 but the clinical stations can be anything from JC1,2 or 3. We have had no information about how many stations there will be, what each station will be examining, what happens with the CCCI lectures we receive, and also the timing for each station and other details like that.

Thank you very much & I look forward to hearing from you.

Warmest regards,
Mark Tan

I NEVER got a reply, so I sent another email:

From: Mark Kiak Min Tan
Sent: Wed 11/28/2007 2:04 PM
To: Dr. XY

Cc: Dr. D
Subject: FW: CC Revision Classes

HI Dr. XY,

I am attaching the email that I sent last Thursday, of which I have yet to receive a reply.

I am just resending it in case you did not receive it. Hopefully you will be to give a quick reply as I do not foresee much time available if we delay for much longer.

Thank you very much,

Regards,
Mark Tan

This time she DID reply, but with a negative:

Dear Mark,

I received your email, with thanks. I had to review this issue with DR. C before replying. As we are unable to provide additional tuition for the full class, these extra sessions cannot be permitted. We appreciate Dr. D's commitment, and are very grteful for her commitment to the programme. All teaching must be standardised, as I am sure you can understand.

I hope this answers your query,

Kind regards

I replied:

Hi Dr. XY,

Thanks for that quick reply. I do understand that it is hard to organise a whole class revision session, but in the light that we are being tested on content from previous semesters in addition to confusion with the course this term, no thanks to room changes and also to lack of equipment, I think that we should be entitled to a session where we can raise our doubts and queries. I do understand that teaching has to be standardised but what we are requesting for approval of a private initiative by the students of the group, who have a demonstrator who is agreeable to our request to conduct a review lesson, and not for the coordinators of this course to organised a whole class revision session.

You have also not addressed the other issue I mentioned in the email regarding the structure of the OSCE exams for JC3. I feel that we should have been given information about this earlier, as with all the other exams, so that we have adequate preparation. Without this information, which even the demonstrators have no idea about, I feel that we have not been sufficiently prepared for the course and exam and is another reason why we feel we need a review session. Would it be possible for you to explain the structure of the OSCE exams for JC3?

Thank you very much.

To which she replied with the most stupid statements:

Dear Mark,

I am unsure as to how some room changes, of which students were informed well in advance of the classes, (I check Moodle every day, at an average of a 3 hourly basis, and I was caught off guard once with the room changes) could affect the delivery of the course content. I would appreciate if you could clarify what you mean by "confusion with the course", (my group did not have a video taping device for one of the session, and when we got one for the next, it had no memory; we had non patient for another session and Dr.XY herself had to step in as the patient; during my first session I was not able to log into Moodle to sign in for the session; we were supposed to get the same tutor for the whole semester, but during our last session this was changed, and the other tutor did not know what to teach, and those are just to name a few...) as I have not received any communication from any students, including yourself, querying this , up until now - I am always available to discuss any issues, but I can't anticipate if uninformed. (I personally approached her regarding the issue of logging in to Moodle for attendance, and if she cannot recall that, I have emails as proof of correspondence, I am sure other students went to see her also, and if they didn't it's because they didn't know who she was, or where to find her, because she does not have an office and her name is not listed as the module coordinator)

I understand that it is a private initiative, but I'm sure you can understand that the rest of the class may feel disgruntled when they cannot avail of such an opportunity.(I am sure they will be, which is why I am writing to you in November, so that you can set up one for the whole class if need be for January, is 2 months not sufficient?) It is unfortunate that this issue is only now brought to my attention - it is usual practice for the class representatives to approach me during the semester, if any additional tuition/classes are requested by the majority of the student body. (At this point, I approached the class reps and they assured me that something would be done...) All such requests are given great consideration by the faculty, and every effort is made to facilitate students, where resources and time allows. (The result of this consideration I will post below, look out for it...)

I have brought your concerns to the attention of Dr. Barry, who is the module coordinator, and to whom such issues should be addressed. Any decisions made on course delivery rest within her remit.

After this fiasco of emails, I emailed the class reps, who assured me that they would bring this matter up with the Junior Cycle Director, and a couple of weeks back, during the Christmas Holidays, I received notice that they had agreed to a tutorial.

The first week of school resumed, and no word of a tutorial was heard. Our OSCE's were to be held the following Thursday and Friday.

Over the weekend, a thread was started asking how many people would be interested in a CC tutorial and a whole bunch of people replied with an affirmative response, and we hoped that our request was being seriously requested.

Anyway, on Monday, we received a strange reply:

Clinical Competencies Revision Session
by Denise O Mara - Monday, 7 January 2008, 03:42 PM

Dear All

A revision session on the clinical competencies content of JC III will be held at 13:00 in the O'Flanagan Lecture Theatre. The format of this session will be Questions & Answers

And one of my classmates posted this up as a reply:

One of the CC ladies (Dr.XY herself) turned up at 1pm in O'Flanagan to give a tutorial and was wondering why no one showed up.

Anyway, I just had to post this because yesterday one of my friends told me that I shoul dbe thankful because this lady was doing us a favour... but that's only because they didn't know the truth, and what happened before that...

Monday, November 26

Awakening of the Sleeping Dragon...

I have long resolved not to post anything involved with politics and have tried to be as objective as possible in my posting, but that's only because these were regarding issues that did not involve me in person.

I received an email this morning, which was infuriating, and has extremely annoyed me. I think it warrant a whole article written in rebuttal, but I do not have the time. I am not one to move rashly and always try to verify my facts before speaking, and after doing a little research, I found what the email contained to be true, and that was when I was most distraught.

Anyway, here are the two excerpts and the cover of the document which in my opinion are credible enough for me to take them as truth that such a thing actually happened. Click on each one to read further if you understand Bahasa.













And this is the unofficial translation of the hansard at the Third Meeting of The Fourth Session of the Eleventh Parliament (Dewan Rakyat) on Monday, 29 October 2007 as seen at http://www.parlimen.gov.my/hindex/pdf/DR-29102007.pdf - pages 143-144.

Tuan Syed Hood bin Syed Edros [Parit Sulong]: Yang Di-Pertua, I would like to touch on a matter regarding the Ministry of Education, which are Christian missionary schools like Convent, La Salle, Methodist, and so forth. I was made to understand that the Board of Directors at these schools are partially administered by churches in foreign countries, for example in the Vatican City. I was also made to understand that the application to build a ’surau’ in some of these schools had to go through the approval of these Board of Directors whereby they are partially administered by the church. Therefore, it shames me that the school administrations are still controlled by the church. I was also made to understand that many Muslim parents send their kids to these schools, and that they have complained that sometimes, the school is started with church songs. I do not know if this is true, but what I discovered from these parents are the display of religious symbols. I feel disappointed that in an Islamic country, Malaysia, if I go to a convent school, the statue of St. Mary is displayed in the front of the school.

Datuk Haji Mohamad bin Haji Aziz [Sri Gading]: [Stands up]

Tuan Syed Hood bin Syed Edros [Parit Sulong]: Please proceed, Yang Berhormat for Sri Gading.

Timbalan Yang di-Pertua [Datuk Dr. Yusof bin Yacob]: Yes, Yang Berhormat for Sri Gading.

Datuk Haji Mohamad bin Haji Aziz [Sri Gading]: I am not shocked at all, Yang Berhormat for Parit Sulong. It’s not just a simple question. The question is, why has this happened? One. During the last Hari Raya, I was told by a father, when Aidilfitri was celebrated, these types of schools were not closed. Thank you.

Tuan Syed Hood bin Syed Edros [Parit Sulong]: Not only statues, but fellow Yang Berhormat, go and see for yourselves, Christian crosses are displayed in front of schools. I do not understand the Ministry of Education, did the officers not see that, or is it our policy to allow such a thing? Nevertheless, I, as a responsible person to my religion, race, and country, I state my views that these statues need to be demolished, these crosses need to be destroyed and church influences in these schools need to be stopped. Also, the funds that are collected at these schools. Do we have a report? If possible, the ministry should reveal the funds for these schools. I was made to understand that these schools are also sponsored by the church.

The translation was taken from
http://www.darnmalaysia.com/2007/11/23/morons-of-parliament-demolish-christian-statues-destroy-the-crosses/

Anyway, what the email also stated was as follows:

The duo’s irresponsible and unsubstantiated comments clearly demonstrate their glaring narrow-mindedness and TOTAL IGNORANCE of the following; thus distracting and sabotaging the way forward and urgent progressive steps being taken by the Government to arrest the decline in competitiveness and to rebuild the nation:

  1. The Constitution of Malaysia (Read Part II, Articles 11 and 12 at http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Malaysia)

  2. Absolute no idea how mission schools are run and conducted in the best interest of the nation-building.

  3. Among the distinguished old boys from mission school Sekolah Menengah Kebangsaan St John Kuala Lumpur, or St John's Institution are Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak, Education Minister Datuk Hishammuddin Hussein, the Raja Muda of Perak, Raja Dr Nazrin Shah, Sultan of Selangor Sultan Sharafuddin Idris Shah, just to name a few.

  4. Mission schools are not fully Government funded, but categorized as a "sekolah bantuan modal" or Government aided school. This means that for many needs including school building projects and maintenance, the school would have to find its own funds.

  5. The Government’s stand on mission schools as announced in the various media as seen at Assunta Alumni’s news archive on mission schools at http://www.assuntaalumni.com/media/missionschools.html

The email also asked for people to sign up for a petition which is available online regarding a more specific issue, but which in a larger frame may set a precedence for future government policy making.

PETITION: Respect the Ethos and Character of Mission Schools
http://www.petitiononline.com/assunta/petition.html
Please note that the above Assunta online petition is still ON (initiated early April 2005). Subsequently, we wrote to the Minister of Education and relevant education departments on 15 June 2005. We hope to see this redressed before school resumes in January 2008 and as we are going to celebrate Assunta Golden Jubilee next year:

Please sign the petition online if you have not done so. All past students of mission schools and the public are also encouraged to sign the above Online Petition. Just state the school you are from. A gentle reminder: Please do not flame at the online petition as we’ll be submitting to the relevant authorities again if need be. Flames will be deleted, positive and constructive comments are most welcomed.

p.s. the words in white are mine , and the ones in yellow are from the email...